0 views
0 comments
0 min read

One-of-a-Kind: Why No Two Lilly & Jude Bags Are the Same

Excerpt

"Buying a mass-produced designer bag is a bit like paying gallery prices for a postcard of a famous painting. You've paid like it's rare, but it's a print, one of thousands, and everyone in the gift shop queue is holding the same one."

|Kerry Atterbury
Blog banner image of a turquoise leather slouchy bag on a grey background and a splash of orange paint splattered on the wall

There's a question I get asked more than almost any other: "Can you make me another one exactly like it?"

And the honest answer is no. I can't. Not because I'm being precious about it or because it's some marketing gimmick, but because it's physically impossible. The hide that made your bag is gone. There isn't another one, and it's that uniqueness that makes every single piece so special.

No factories. No patterns cut a thousand times over.

Every Lilly & Jude bag starts life as an offcut or a scrap, leather that a manufacturer somewhere has thrown out for being too small, too odd a shape, or too "flawed" to be worth their while. I rescue it before it can end up in landfill and turn it into a genuinely one of a kind handbag, not a copy of one.

I actually love those flaws. The marks, the grain variations, the bits a factory would reject on sight, they're not something I try to hide or work around. They add character and interest that a pristine, uniform hide never could. I work with whatever the scraps present me with, and because every single piece of rescued leather is different, so is every rescued leather bag cut from it.

Compare that to the mass-produced designer bags lining the shelves of every high street. Same pattern. Same factory. Same bag, repeated thousands of times over, until "luxury" starts to feel a bit... hollow. You've paid a premium, and what you've got is just expensive, not special. And frankly, this mass production is soul crushingly boring, and not all that great for the environment either.

I wanted to do things differently.

Yes, I reuse some patterns.
No, that doesn't make them the same bag.

I'll be honest with you, because that's how I do things: some of my designs do use the same pattern more than once. The Starburn, the Estrella, the Tiny Harriet, these are shapes I come back to because they work, and because my fabulous customers love them!

But here's the bit that matters. The leather is always different. The lining is always different. The hardware, the straps, the little finishing details, all of it changes bag to bag, because it has to. I'm not sat here with a roll of identical leather churning the same bag out fifty times over. I'm working with whatever rescued hide I've got in front of me that week, in whatever colour and texture it happens to be, paired with fabric that's often genuinely one-off itself (misprints, deadstock, end-of-roll, remnants that would otherwise go to waste too).

So yes, you might spot the same silhouette on two different bags. What you'll never spot is the same bag.

Three small zippered pouches with diagonal stitched detailing, shown side by side on a white background. The pouches are in sage green, cream, and bright pink.
Same DNA, wildly different personalities.
Hot pink, small crossbody bag with a colourful leopard print strap on a white background
Tiny Harriet | Hot Pink Leather Compact Crossbody Bag
£55.00
View product
Upcycled denim compact crossbody bag with tan brown leather trim and matching woven strap on a white background
Tiny Harriet | Denim & Leather Compact Crossbody Bag
£55.00
View product
A four-panel collage showing stacks of raw leather rolls and strips in multiple colours, with a pale sage green handbag placed on top in the top-right panel.

Scrap-tastic!

Why this matters more than just
"Oh, that's cool"

It's easy to think uniqueness is just a nice-to-have, a bit of marketing polish. But there's something bigger going on underneath it.

Making bags this way means I can't churn out stock the way a factory does. Every single bag takes time, thought and care, because every hide behaves a little differently and every design has to work with what that particular piece of leather gives me. That slower pace is deliberate. It's what keeps quality high and waste low, and it's the reason rescued leather can become something genuinely beautiful instead of just "recycled" in the vague, feel-good sense of the word.

A burgundy leather handbag with silver-tone hardware and a small metal brand plaque, standing on a light gray surface against a textured, abstract painted background.

Not a postcard. The actual painting.

Can I be a bit cheeky for a second?

I find it genuinely baffling that people will drop hundreds, sometimes thousands, of pounds on a bag purely because of the name stamped on it, when that exact same bag has been mass-produced in a factory alongside thousands of identical siblings. You're not buying something rare. You're buying something with a very good marketing department behind it.

Buying a mass-produced designer bag is a bit like paying gallery prices for a postcard of a famous painting. You've paid like it's rare, but it's a print, one of thousands, and everyone in the gift shop queue is holding the same one. A Lilly & Jude bag is the original hanging on the wall, just without the gallery price tag attached to it. Now, I'm not about to compare myself to a great artist (my imposter syndrome would never let me get away with that one), but you get my point. Nobody looks at a postcard of a Van Gogh and thinks it's basically the same as owning the original. Except somehow, with handbags, we've all been trained to believe exactly that.

A beige textured leather belt bag with silver zippers, displayed on a white pedestal in an art gallery with colourful abstract paintings in the background.

Gallery-Worthy-Bags

Are Lilly & Jude Bags Expensive?

So are my bags expensive? Well that depends what you're comparing them to.

Next to a Primark handbag, yes, mine cost more.

Next to a Hermès Birkin? I'd have to laugh uncontrollably, then explain that you could probably buy my entire business for less than half the price of a half decent second-hand Birkin 30.

With a Lilly & Jude bag, what you're actually paying for is something handcrafted, and a limited edition of exactly one. You're not paying the designer logo tax either, so my bags don't cost the earth, in either sense of the phrase.

But hey, I've got big plans, and one day I'd love to be able to charge "Birkin" prices with a straight face. I'm not there yet. So for now, just think of buying a Lilly & Jude bag as your chance to own an original, before I got famous! #Manifesting #AreYouThereUniverseItsMeKerry

Sold out?! Ack!! Someone else got there first!

Want a Bag that's Sold Out?

Sorry. No can do, mon ami.

I get it, I really do. If you've seen a bag on here and fallen in love with it, it's disappointing to hear you can't have an identical one. But here's the bit I hope softens that blow: I can very often make something inspired by it, in a similar leather, a similar shape, a similar feel, just with its own personality. You'll get something that captures what you loved, but that's entirely, unmistakably yours.

Because honestly? You don't want the same bag as everyone else. You just think you do because that's what fast fashion has trained us to want.

What you actually want is a genuinely unique handbag that feels like it was made for you, with you in mind. Which my bags are.

Now... to make sure that you don't miss out on future releases, I thoroughly recommend that you join the VIP list (for free + I'll send you a 10% voucher for you to use on your first purchase!). Just fill in the form below ⬇️

WANT FIRST LOOK BEFORE A PIECE EVEN MAKES IT TO THE SHOP?

Don't miss out on future exclusive releases. Join our VIP list for early access to new collections, secret sales and special offers.

You'll also get a 10% voucher to use on your first purchase!

By submitting this form, you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Ready to Find Your One-of-a-Kind Bag?

I really hate to sound all sales-y, but every bag on this site is genuinely one of one.

Once it's sold, it's properly gone, no reprints, no restocks, no "just like it."

Have a browse, and if something stops you in your tracks, that's your answer. Someone else won't wait either.

Shop Bags
An olive green pebbled leather shoulder bag with a slouchy hobo shape, resting on a concrete floor with vibrant orange and blue paint splatters against a white wall background.
Butter yellow cream  leather crossbody bag with a strap on a white background
Starburn | Butter Yellow Leather Crossbody Bag
£95.00
View product
Taupe leather handbag with matching wallet and keychain on a white background
Juliette Deluxe Gift Set | Handcrafted Taupe Grey Leather Bag + Accessories
£200.00
View product
A gray leather handbag with a silver chain strap and a small silver-tone logo plaque, shown on a plain white background.
Flossy | Grey Leather Slouchy Handbag with Chain Strap
£150.00
View product
A green leather shoulder bag with a shoulder strap and a zipper closure, displayed against a plain background.
Paulette | Sage Green Slouchy Leather Shoulder Bag
£140.00
View product

QUICK QUESTIONS, HONEST ANSWERS...

CAN I ORDER A BAG THAT'S OUT OF STOCK?

No. Sorry. Every bag is cut from its own piece of rescued leather, so once it's sold, that specific bag is gone for good. I can make you something inspired by it, just never identical.

Now... if your heart is absolutely set on a bag that's gone to its forever home, then you can get in touch with me via the contact page, and we can have a discussion to see if I can make something similar. I don't currently offer a bespoke service, but I can sometimes add similar bags to my 'to make' list. I can't make any promises, but I will always try to accommodate you.

QUICK QUESTIONS, HONEST ANSWERS

Why do some designs share the same pattern?

A handful of my most-loved shapes, like the Flossy and Starburn, get reused because they simply work and people ask for them again and again. What never repeats is the leather, the lining, the hardware and the straps, so the pattern might be familiar but the bag never is.

How do I make sure I don't miss out on a bag I love?

Don't sit on it. Once it's gone, it's properly gone.

Joining the VIP list is the best way to see new one-of-a-kind pieces the moment they land, before they're live on the main shop (and usually with a nice discount voucher to go along with it!).

Handcrafted in the UK
Made from genuine rescued leather
Free shipping on orders over £150

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.